Before testing
We record the price paid, where it came from, and whether the unit was bought, borrowed or supplied. Supplied units are returned or bought at full price after the review. We do not accept conditions on coverage.
Battery
Laptops and phones run a fixed workload: a browser with twelve tabs cycling every thirty seconds, a video call at 720p for one hour, and a local video loop. Screen brightness is set to 150 nits, measured with a meter. We report the time to shutdown, not the time to a warning.
Sustained load and heat
We run a thirty minute render and record clock speed, fan noise at arm's length and surface temperature at the keyboard and the underside. A machine that is fast for ninety seconds and slow afterwards is a slow machine, and we score it that way.
Display
Brightness in nits, contrast, colour coverage and reflectance. For phones we also test outdoor readability at noon, because that is when people use them.
Daily use
Every product is used as a daily driver for at least a month by the reviewer. Software bugs, sleep problems and update behaviour only show up in that window, and they matter more than a benchmark.
What the scores mean
Nine and above: class leading, buy it without caveats. Eight to eight point nine: excellent, with one compromise worth knowing. Seven to seven point nine: good, and the compromise is real. Six to six point nine: acceptable if the price drops. Below six: we do not recommend it.
Re-testing
Reviews are re-checked after six months for price and software changes. If a score changes, the article is updated with a note explaining why, and the date changes. The URL never changes. Read the corrections policy for how we handle factual errors.
