Switching broadband and mobile at the end of a contract saves substantially more than haggling does, according to a Which? survey of 5,014 UK adults published this morning. Customers who moved broadband, TV and mobile together could save up to £429 a year in combination, and the gap between switching and staying to negotiate is wider than most people assume.
The survey asked people whose broadband, broadband and TV, or mobile contract had ended in the previous year whether they switched, haggled, or did nothing. Data was collected online in July and August 2026.
Switching beats haggling on every contract type
The averages are not close.
| Contract | Average saving by switching | Average saving by haggling | |---|---|---| | Mobile only | £93 | £42 | | Broadband only | £106 | £50 | | Broadband and TV | £171 | £82 |
One case stands well clear of the rest. Mobile customers who moved from a contract that included a handset to a SIM-only deal once the phone was paid off saved an average of £258 a year. That is the single largest saving in the survey, and it is the easiest one to make, because the handset is already yours.
Leaving a large provider also pays. Customers who left EE saved an average of £161 a year, and those who left O2 saved £142.
Haggling is not worthless, but it wins less often. Roughly 54 to 59 per cent of people who haggled made a saving, against 74 to 84 per cent of those who switched. If you are happy with your provider, a polite call to the retentions team is still worth twenty minutes. If you are indifferent, moving is the better use of the same twenty minutes.
The people who lose the most are the ones who do nothing
Thirteen per cent of mobile customers took no action at all when their contract ended. That compares with 5 per cent of broadband customers and 2 per cent of those with a broadband and TV bundle.
Doing nothing is not neutral. A contract that has run its term usually rolls onto a higher monthly price, and the handset you have already paid for keeps being charged for.
Three situations where you should act this week
- Your phone contract has ended. If you are still paying for a handset you own, you are paying a handset subsidy for nothing. Move to a SIM-only deal.
- A premium TV offer is expiring. Introductory pricing on film and sport bundles rises sharply at the end of the term, and the bundle is only good value if you actually watch most of it.
- You cannot remember when your contract ended. Check the date, then diarise it. The whole saving depends on acting in the window after the minimum term.
It is easier than it used to be
Most people who switched said it was simple: 84 per cent of broadband customers and 84 per cent of mobile customers described it as easy, along with 77 per cent of broadband and TV customers.
Two rules did most of that work. One Touch Switch means you only tell the provider you are joining and they handle the transfer from the old one. Text to Switch does the same job for mobile, by text message and with a code you pass to the new network. Neither requires a call to the company you are leaving.
What to do before you switch
- Check whether you are still inside a minimum term, because exit fees can wipe out the saving
- Write down what you actually use: data volume, whether you need a landline, which channels you watch
- Get two quotes at the same speed tier, not the headline price of the cheapest package
- Ask your current provider for its retention price before you accept either quote
If you are moving to a SIM-only plan, check that your phone supports an eSIM before you sign up, because what an eSIM does changes how you transfer between networks. And if the move coincides with a sale, read how to spot a fake Black Friday discount first, because a discount on a raised price is not a saving.
The bottom line
Switching saves roughly double what haggling does, and the biggest single win is dropping to SIM-only once your handset is paid off. Put the end date of every contract in your calendar now, so the decision happens while you still have leverage. The one thing not to do is nothing.


